Submit a Story!
Best Anti-Stimulus Argument: from Kevin Murphy
Matthew Yglesias agrees that Kevin Murphy gives the: Best Anti-Stimulus Argument I’ve Seen : Kevin Murphy’s slides here. I think he overstates the deadweight loss effect and is working with the wrong conception of “efficiency” for these purposes when he claims that ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

A structure for our value judgments
The visible hand in economics — Earlier I mentioned that Paul Walker and myself had different ideas surrounding the need for a stimulus in the US. Fundamentally I think he is completely against while I see scope for some stimulus. Over at Brad Delong’s blog he mentions a description of the stimulus by Kevin Murphy. The structure he describes is below: Evaluating the Fiscal Stimulus Kevin M. Murphy January 16, 2009 A Framework for Thinking about the Stimulus Package Let G = increase in government ...

Assorted links
Marginal Revolution — 1. Good things Obama has done. 2. A paper in support of fiscal policy. 3. Summary of Kevin Murphy on stimulus. 4. Political scientists in the movies.

But Brad Please Tell Your Readers That Many Economists Said Bush Was Horrible from the Start
The Austrian Economists — ... One of President Bush's first acts in power was to provide aid to the steel industry.  And several economist on the "right" voiced their opposition.  However, readers on Brad de Long's blog continue to suggest that market oriented economists are only voicing opposition to Obama due to partisanship.  Brad seems to reinforce this impression.  Even while admitting that Kevin Murphy raises some strong points in his critique of fiscal stimulus, he raises questions about what would change Murphy's priors. ...

Alpha = 0?
TRUTH ON THE MARKET — ... resources * Ricardian equivalence implies that people will save to pay for future taxes reducing private spending * ? is non-zero and likely to be substantial * People place positive value on their time * Unemployed resources produce value through relocation (e.g. mobility & job search) * d is likely to be significant * Wide range of estimates of d * Estimates based on the analysis of taxable income imply d?0.8 * With these parameters the stimulus package is likely to be a bad idea Brad DeLong calls this the best anti-stimulus argument he’s seen and suggests that perhaps the ...

Murphy vs. DeLong and the macroeconomics of my youth
Newmark's Door — ... Brad DeLong of Cal-Berkeley, accepting the inequality for the sake of argument, gives different estimates of the four parameters and concludes the benefits are much greater. ...

Related Content
Top Ten Facts About Kevin M. Murphy
evanmiller.org 2/28/2009 — 10. Kevin Murphy just ate the stimulus package for breakfast. 9. Kevin Murphy once found a Giffen good in his refrigerator. 8. There are no monopolies. There are only firms Kevin Murphy has decided not to compete against...yet. 7. Q: Robert Barro and ...
An Anti-Stimulus Conference
econlog.econlib.org 2/4/2009 — (January 29, 2009 06:11 PM, by Arnold Kling) See the invitation below. My theme will be "what certified macroeconomists think about the stimulus bill."...
Interview with Kevin Murphy - The Region - Publications & Papers | The Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis
minneapolisfed.org 6/27/2009 — The first thing you notice about Kevin Murphy is the baseball cap. Amid the imperious architecture and soaring intellects (or vice versa) of the University of Chicago, the cap is disarming. It immediately sets you at ease. This is a guy you can talk ...
How economists analyze the stimulus - The Atlantic Business Channel
business.theatlantic.com 1/26/2009 — Two economists on opposite sides of the stimulus debate recently expressed their opinions in terms of algebra. The opponent, Kevin Murphy of the University of Chicago, laid out the basic framework at a panel where he was the second speaker. The ...
Huizinga, Lucas, and Murphy
gregmankiw.blogspot.com 1/28/2009 — Click here to watch a great panel discussion from the University of Chicago about the economy and proposed fiscal plans.
Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee, GATA, Chairman Bill Murphy Interview (video)
youtube.com 3/25/2009 — Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee, GATA, and Chairman Bill Murphy Interview with Bernie Lo24th March 2009Better video here quailty here, the live stream from ...
Opinion: There's No Stimulus Free Lunch
online.wsj.com 2/10/2009 — GARY S. BECKER and KEVIN M. MURPHY How much will the stimulus package moving in Congress really stimulate the economy? The evaluations to date have been incomplete, so we looked at the likely stimulative effect from the spending parts of the House and ...
Kevin Drum - Mother Jones Blog: Kevin Drum Smackdown Watch
motherjones.com 1/20/2009 — Kevin, there's already a bank nationalization/recapitalization mechanism in this country that works reasonably well, which is an FDIC takeover. The FDIC prefers to immediately sell banks that it takes over, but it doesn't always do that. Sometimes it ...
Does "Depression Economics" Change the Rules? - Robert P. Murphy - Mises Institute
mises.org 1/12/2009 — Let me explain through an example why I don't think these objections [of crowding out and job destruction from higher taxes or borrowing] do not apply to depression economies. Imagine a town with a widget factory that provides employment for workers ...
Bad anti-stimulus arguments
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com 12/23/2008 — A number of conservative economists have been arguing against a stimulus plan centered on government spending. Fair enough. But one argument I keep reading bugs me: it's the claim that spending-based stimulus is bad because economic theory tells us ...
Wrong HarryThe Big Money 1/27/2009
President Obama's $825 billion economic-stimulus package needs a lot less PWA and a lot more CWA. The PWA was the Public Works Administration, led by Harold Ickes Sr. The CWA was the Civil Works Administration, led by Harry Hopkins. Both were ...
On George Bush, bankruptcy laws, Brazil's border, lawsuits, Scotland, Helen Suzman, corporate jetsThe Economist: Full print edition 1/29/2009
SIR – The headline to your briefing on George Bush’s legacy (“The frat boy ships out”, January 17th) spoke volumes of the sneering, snarling disdain you hold for the man, which is so strong that it overwhelms your objectivity. ...
Broadband stimulus: Not so fastThe Economist: Full print edition 1/29/2009
There is much talk about subsidies for high-speed broadband, but other causes are more deserving IN HIS first radio address as president, Barack Obama spoke of “expanding broadband to millions of Americans”. Britain’s prime ...
Trade policy: Buying AmericanThe Economist: Full print edition 1/29/2009
Economic nationalism rears its ugly head IN 1929 Willis Hawley and Reed Smoot, two protectionist Republicans in Congress, sponsored a bill to raise tariffs to the highest levels America had ever seen. And in the midst of economic distress, the ...
Technology stimulus plans: Paved with good intentionsThe Economist: Full print edition 1/29/2009
Is “broadband for all” a recipe for recovery, or a boondoggle? BEGGING for government help would have made you a pariah in most parts of the high-tech industry a few months ago. But these days state aid, and how to dole it out, are ...