Submit a Story!
topics:

Check the Numbers: The Case for Due Diligence in Policy Formation
Empirical research in academic journals is often cited as the basis for public policy decisions, in part because people think that the journals have checked the accuracy of the research. Yet such work is rarely subjected to independent checks for accuracy during the peer review process, and the ...
Comments
Blog Reactions

Case for due diligence in public policy
Peter Gallagher — ... policy decisions, in part because people think that the journals have checked the accuracy of the research. Yet such work is rarely subjected to independent checks for accuracy during the peer review process, and the data and computational methods are so seldom disclosed that post-publication verification is equally rare. This study argues that researchers and journals have allowed habits of secrecy to persist that severely inhibit independent replication. " Extract from Check the Numbers: The Case for Due Diligence in Policy Formation ...

Links 2/22/09
naked capitalism — Runaway horse in French capital BBC (see another video here, hat tip reader Michael T). Look for the way the gendame catches Garabaldi. Surveillance cams help fight crime, city says Chicago Sun-Times. Big Brother is coming to the Midwest. Check the Numbers: The Case for Due Diligence in Policy Formation Fraser Institute (hat tip Felix Salmon) Radical revamp splits RBS in two Times Online The Complete Biggest Losers! Clusterstock. While Rome Burns Ed Harrison 'Good Banks' ...

Related: the case for due diligence in policy formation
Must reading for social scientists who care at all about public policy
newmarksdoor.typepad.com 2/23/2009 — Read Bruce D. McCullough and Ross McKitrick's new paper, " Check the Numbers: The Case for Due Diligence in Policy Formation ". (I thank Professor McCullough for the pointer.) From the beginning, where the authors classify ...