Submit a Story!
Economic View - The Public Option -  A Distraction in the Health Care Debate - News Analysis
Economic View - The Public Option - A Distraction in the Health Care Debate - News Analysis
WE clearly don’t need any more distractions from the two main issues of health care reform : how to deal with our large uninsured population and how to make the entire system more cost effective. So, for now, let’s ignore the shouted rhetoric about whether “death panels” want to kill off ...
Health-Care Reform: Do Animals or People Get Better Care?
online.wsj.com — THEODORE DALRYMPLE In the last few years, I have had the opportunity to compare the human and... veterinary health services of Great Britain, and on the whole it is better to be a dog. As a British dog, you get to choose (through an intermediary, I ... (more) Health-Care Reform: Do Animals or People Get Better Care?
Op-Ed Contributors - A Public Option That Works
Op-Ed Contributors - A Public Option That Works
nytimes.com — TWO burning questions are at the center of America’s health care debate. First, should employers be required... to pay for their employees’ health insurance? And second, should there be a “public option” that competes with private insurance? Answers ... (more) Op-Ed Contributors - A Public Option That Works
Video - Obama: Time to work together on health care
politicalnewslive.blogspot.com — President Barack Obama is asking Americans to lower the volume of the rhetoric over his health care... proposal while acknowledging "legitimate differences" worthy of discussion. (more) Video - Obama: Time to work together on health care
Comments
Blog Reactions

Thaler on the Public Option
Greg Mankiw's BlogHere is Richard Thaler on the public option in the healthcare debate. He ends up about where I was in June when I wrote on this topic, but I think he is a bit too quick to "assume that the public option does have to break even and can’t make any special deals." I believe that many advocates and many opponents of the public option are making the opposite assumption and, as a result, see the public option as a route toward a single-payer system. (They disagree, however, whether that is good or bad.) That is why the public option is a bigger issue in this debate than Thaler ...

Assorted links
Marginal Revolution — 1. Gerald Dworkin on G.A. Cohen. 2. Possible furloughs for UC professors. 3. Critique of libertarianism, built around Monty Python quotations. 4. Bruce Bueno de Mesquita and his predictions. 5. Richard Thaler on the public plan. 6. Sarah Lyell on the NHS.

"A Public Option Isn't a Curse or a Cure"
Economist's View — ... A Public Option Isn’t a Curse, or a Cure, by Richard Thaler, Commentary, NY Times: We clearly don’t need any more distractions from the two main issues of health care reform: how to deal with our large uninsured population and how to make the entire system more cost effective. ...[O]ne big distraction remains: the question of whether a “public option” should be part of the health care solution. To me, the issue is a red herring, and is getting in the way of genuine reform. ...

10 Links: Monday Edition
The Big Picture — ... time: • For FDIC, Friday Means Failures (The Deal) Each Friday night, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. preps its SWAT teams of regulators to fan out and secure more banks. No one other than FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair and her staff know for certain who’s next after 72 banks failed this year, almost 3 times as many as last year’s 25.  see also BB&T Acquires Colonial as Regulators Close Five U.S. Lenders (Bloomberg) • Behavioral Economist Richard Thaler on the Health Care debate (NYT) ...

The Public Plan, Again
Greg Mankiw's Blog — The possibility of including a public plan in the health reform bill is on the table again. Here are a few viewpoints on the topic: Robert Samuelson, Paul Krugman, Richard Thaler, and me. ...

Related: what's bad about the public option?, public option health care
links for 2009-08-16
economistsview.typepad.com 8/16/2009 — The Public Option - A Distraction in the Health Care Debate - NYTimes.com California's universities in trouble - The Economist Why We Need Health Care Reform - Barack Obama More on deficits and interest rates (wonkish) - Paul Krugman  ...
"Public Option versus “Co-ops”: The Market Test"
economistsview.typepad.com 8/18/2009 — What do prediction and financial markets have to say about the prospect of dropping the public option and replacing it with health care co-ops? Here's Arin Dube with a follow-up to this post with an answer you probably won't like: Public ...
Bad Analogy, Mr. PresidentClub for Growth
Obama tries to make the case for a public health care option by comparing it to the Post Office. D'oh!
Dropping the 'public option' could insure some stocks' healthBloggingStocks
Regardless of how you feel about a public health insurance option offered by the government, interest at the policy level seems to be waning recently. If Democrats drop the idea of a public option as a component of health care reform, health insurance companies could benefit. The way I see it, ...
Thaler’s Unsound Argument About the Public Insurance OptionTRUTH ON THE MARKET
University of Chicago economist (and behavioralist doyen) Richard Thaler thinks "the question of whether a 'public option' should be part of the health care solution" is just "one big distraction." In Sunday's New York Times, Thaler argues that the debate over the public option is a "red ...
White House Blurs Stance on Public OptionBreaking News: CBS News
AP Factcheck: White House Denies Backtracking on Government-Run Health Care Option, but Record Begs to Differ
How Tough Is Our President?Daily Markets
Latest word from the White House is that the President still supports a public option but is also standing by Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius’s remark last weekend that a public insurance plan is “not the essential element” of health-care reform. So ...
Tuesday's Daily NewsClub for Growth
THE DAILY NEWS Key Dems Say Public Option is Essential - Kornblut and Bacon, Wash Post Liberals Revolt Over Public Option - Martin and Brown, The Politico The Public Option Goes Over - Wall Street Journal Editorial Watching A Bad Idea Implode - IBD Editorial About Those Health Care ...
Top Democrats Stand Firm on Public OptionBreaking News: CBS News
Washington Post: Lawmakers Predict Health Care Bill Could Lose Several Votes Without It
Public Option, Cooperatives or a CooperativeAngry Bear
Robert Waldmann can't resist writing about health care reform. The actual debate seems very focused on the public option -- will the minority of Americans who have access to the new insurance exchanges have the opportunity to buy health insurance from the US government. Notably this is the ...
Health-Care Failure a Symptom of Washington's Bigger IllsYahoo! Finance: Tech Ticker
Will the President abandon the public health insurance option in order to pass some kind of health-care reform? That’s the latest decision being bandied about in the West Wing. For now, the White House says, President Obama "believes the publ
Health-Care Reform: A Cure That's Worse Than the DiseaseYahoo! Finance: Tech Ticker
After President Obama and two key aides backtracked this weekend on the need for a public option, a lot of critics - including many Democrats - are saying health-care reform is a good idea falling victim to bad execution.
Health Care Reform: The Public Option’s Last Stand, And The Public’sDaily Markets
I would have preferred a single payer system like Medicare, but became convinced earlier this year that a public, Medicare-like optional plan was just about as much as was politically possible. Now the White House is stepping back even from the public option, with the President saying ...
"The Public Option as a Signal"Economist's View
More from Paul Krugman on the public option: The public option as a signal, by Paul Krugman : Look, it is possible to have universal care without a public option; Switzerland does. But there are some good reasons for the prominence of the public option in our debate. One is ...
Odds For A Public Option in 2009 TankBespoke Investment Group
Those following the US health care debate know that comments from the White House this weekend dealt a blow to the "public option" aspect of reform. At the end of July, we posted the odds that traders on Intrade were putting on a "public option" getting signed into law by the end of 2009. After ...
Monday's Daily NewsClub for Growth
THE DAILY NEWS Carol Shea-Porker: Lover of Earmarks - Union Leader Editorial Public Health Care Option May Be Out - Ceci Connolly, Washington Post Real Health Care Reform - Arnold Kling, EconLog Spiders of D.C. Spin Their Webs - Waterbury Republican-American Editorial Debating the ...
Co-ops: A ‘Public Option’ By Another NameCato @ Liberty
Politico reports that the so-called “public option” provision could be dropped from the highly controversial health care bill currently being debated throughout the country: President Barack Obama and his top aides are signaling that they’re prepared to drop a government insurance ...
Stock Picks: AET Up; LOW Down (Market Movers)SmartMoney.com
Health-Care Plan Falters, Giving Insurers a Boost Word that the Obama administration may be backing away from its health-care reform plans and scrapping the so-called public option (a government-run alternative to private insurance) sent investors flocking to insurance stocks Monday. Shares ...
Today’s Playbook On Health Insurance Stocks, Post- Public OptionDaily Markets
In an astute political move, Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sibelius on Sunday said that providing citizens with the option of government-run insurance is not essential to the Obama administration’s overhaul of U.S. health care. Evidently, the administration has caved on ...
Public Private Competition in Garbage CollectionEconomist's View
The public option for health care appears to be dead , so this is a bit late, but I keep hearing that there are no examples of public-private competition, let alone successful ones. But there are examples of this, and they have been successful. We are used to the argument that the private ...
Gibbs: No "Postal Service" for Health CareBreaking News: CBS News
President Still Favors Public Option as a Means of Creating Competition and Choice, the White House Press Secretary Said