Submit a Story!
FT.com / Comment / Opinion - The stimulus is a fiscal straitjacket
The US debate over the fiscal stimulus is remarkable in its neglect of the medium term – that is, the budgetary challenges over a period of five to 10 years. Neither the White House nor Congress has offered the public a scenario of how the proposed mega-deficits will affect the budget and ...
Fiscal stimulus: More needed?
Fiscal stimulus: More needed?
woodwardhall.wordpress.com — The House has passed HR1 and the Senate is working on a counterpart fiscal stimulus bill. We... will discuss HR1 for the sake of specificity and in the belief that the final law will be fairly similar to HR1. The table below shows the Congressional ... (more) Fiscal stimulus: More needed?
"The Tarp is a fiscal straitjacket"
nakedcapitalism.com — This comment by Jeffrey Sachs in the Financial Times is broader than its title suggests. It says... that the US should not run willy-nilly into enacting massive spending plans in haste. Sachs makes two core points: a lot of compromises are being made ... (more) "The Tarp is a fiscal straitjacket"
Barro on Fiscal Stimulus
gregmankiw.blogspot.com — From my Harvard colleague Robert Barro : in terms of fiscal-stimulus proposals, it would be unfortunate if... the best Team Obama can offer is an unvarnished version of Keynes's 1936 "General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money." The financial ... (more) Barro on Fiscal Stimulus
1 Comment
  • hyonh311 hyonh311
    +1
    Majority agree that the real estate market triggered the infamous global depression. The loan programs that offered No income loans, No documentation loans, Stated loans, and the 1 year MTA loans is what truly caused the flaw in the mortgage lending. Why don't they spend that money back into the mortgage lending industry? Loan modifications are one thing, but wouldn't it make sense for lenders to drop the mortgage rate backed by the government stimulus? It only makes sense. All the money being already spent due to the trigger effect in that 1 out of every 5 jobs are real estate related. I don't mean bringing back same kind of programs, but full documentation for borrowers only. That way the loans will not reset into payment shock and can offer the 30 year loan programs. It would certainly revive the global economy and any minimal losses compared to spending $700 billion and can end up to $1.4 trillion total makes sense. As long as a major factor such as real estate stays steady, the economy can be like reverse-engineering where it fixes itself by going back to the cause and still making it easier than now to qualify. The bottom line is that greed caused by the banks and Wall Street forming loan programs that maximizes their return, and didn't anticipate the obvious when loan officers are saying "are you sure you can pay for this. you're debt ratio is already high and you don't make that much as we're going stated or no income, etc..program" Borrowers were greedy too because they knew they couldn't pay it as it is but thinking big gain and short term just like the banks, and Wall Street did was the root of this madness. Real estate is the cure, and the remedy is investing back into mortgage lending by allowing lenders to come up with "benefiticial to borrowers" loan programs and any difference in loss the stimulus money can cover wich would be pennies compared to spending 1.4 trillion.
    Posted 2/6/2009 respond (flag)
Blog Reactions

"The Tarp is a fiscal straitjacket"
naked capitalism — ... in this piece. But Sachs more recently has argued for targeted aid for the poorest nations, contending that they are in a poverty trap, and assistance to get them to a higher level of agricultural productivity could give them the boost they need to overcome chronic deprivation. Whether you agree with all of Sachs' argument, his caution about undue haste is well founded and is consistent with the worries of other macroeconomists such as Willem Buiter. From the Financial Times : The US debate over the fiscal stimulus is ...

Sachs: A Fiscal Straitjacket
Economist's View — ... A fiscal straitjacket, by Jeffrey Sachs, Commentary, Financial Times: The US debate over the fiscal stimulus is remarkable in its neglect of the medium term – that is, the budgetary challenges over a period of five to 10 years. ... Without a sound medium-term fiscal framework, the stimulus package can easily do more harm than good... ...

Washington’s Bubble
Bear Mountain Bull — ... some opinion from the Financial Times : The US debate over the fiscal stimulus is remarkable in its neglect of the medium term – that is, the budgetary challenges over a period of five to 10 years. Neither the White House nor Congress has offered the public a scenario of how the proposed mega-deficits will affect the budget and government programmes beyond the next 12 to 24 months. Without a sound medium-term fiscal framework, the stimulus package can easily do more harm than good, since the prospect of trillion-dollar-plus deficits as far as the eye can see will weigh ...

Errors Galore
winterspeak.com — ... takes the form of additional government debt, the added debt displaces other uses of the same funds. 3. Thus, stimulus plans only enhance incomes when they move resources from less productive to more productive uses. Are any of these statements incorrect?Krugman says 2 is incorrect, and calls Fama pitiful. Krugman, of course, is also pitiful because 1. is wrong too. But I don't have a spot in the NYTimes. 2) Jeffrey Sachs -- has an FT column, which is not that great, Nobel Prize status unknown to me. Still wrong ...

Related Content
The Fiscal Stimulus: What Will Work?
forbes.com 1/9/2009 — Last year at this time, Congress and the White House were so concerned about an economic downturn that they agreed in record time to a $152 billion stimulus bill that sent $300 rebate checks to every taxpayer. The theory was that people would ...
FT.com / Comment / Opinion - We do not need a second stimulus plan
ft.com 7/5/2009 — A s the US unemployment rate has risen to 9.5 per cent from 8.1 per cent since the $787bn fiscal stimulus package was enacted in February, many Democrats have become very nervous. They say that another large stimulus may be needed to keep unemployment ...
FT.com / Comment / Opinion - Do not squander America’s stimulus on tax cuts
ft.com 1/15/2009 — s news of the US economy worsens, worries about whether a stimulus could restart the economy are growing. Making matters more complicated is the fact that our 2009 fiscal deficit will exceed 8 per cent of gross domestic product , even before the ...
Non-arguments Against the Fiscal Stimulus
econospeak.blogspot.com 1/17/2009 — Greg Mankiw has another post where the reader might think there is some argument against the Obama fiscal stimulus proposal – but once again, the reader finds nothing : John Cochrane, a professor at the University of Chicago Booth School of ...
FT.com / Comment / Opinion - A plan to boost America’s fiscal health
ft.com 6/15/2009 — s the healthcare debate picks up in the US, there has been much discussion about how to pay for it. Coinciding with this debate are vocal concerns about the country’s underlying fiscal position – which some have suggested as a reason to delay ...
My Preferred Fiscal Stimulus
gregmankiw.blogspot.com 2/6/2009 — Regular readers of this blog have a pretty good sense of my policy preferences. But for those occasional readers who might be stopping by, let me reiterate what I would do right now if I were the fiscal king. I would institute an immediate and ...
Fama on Fiscal Stimulus
gregmankiw.blogspot.com 1/15/2009 — Eugene Fama is a stimulus skeptic . In fact, he is even more skeptical than I am. I am willing to concede that many Keynesian effects work in the short run, although I prefer monetary policy to fiscal policy and, within fiscal policy, I prefer the ...
U.S. Fiscal Stimulus Revisited
economy.com 8/19/2009 — The moment of truth is at hand for the U.S. fiscal stimulus plan. The stimulus that became law in February should reach its point of maximum economic benefit this summer. If the plan is working, retailing will improve soon, and businesses should ...
A Federalist Fiscal Stimulus
gregmankiw.blogspot.com 11/1/2008 — Many economists are calling for another fiscal stimulus package. For example, Martin Feldstein, who once wrote an article called "The Retreat from Keynesian Economics," recently pulled a full Keynesian in an article in the Washington Post : The only ...
Another Reason Fiscal Stimulus Won't Work: LAGS
mjperry.blogspot.com 1/27/2009 — WASHINGTON POST -- Less than half the money dedicated to highways, school construction and other infrastructure projects in a massive economic stimulus package unveiled by House Democrats is likely to be spent within the next two years, according to ...
Wrong HarryThe Big Money
President Obama's $825 billion economic-stimulus package needs a lot less PWA and a lot more CWA. The PWA was the Public Works Administration, led by Harold Ickes Sr. The CWA was the Civil Works Administration, led by Harry Hopkins. Both were ...
New York and Illinois: Over-mighty governorsThe Economist: Full print edition
It’s time to curb their power to pick senators WHEN David Paterson unexpectedly became governor of New York last year after Eliot Spitzer’s resignation, he impressed everyone by putting the economic crisis before politics. He was doing ...
Broadband stimulus: Not so fastThe Economist: Full print edition
There is much talk about subsidies for high-speed broadband, but other causes are more deserving IN HIS first radio address as president, Barack Obama spoke of “expanding broadband to millions of Americans”. Britain’s prime ...
Technology stimulus plans: Paved with good intentionsThe Economist: Full print edition
Is “broadband for all” a recipe for recovery, or a boondoggle? BEGGING for government help would have made you a pariah in most parts of the high-tech industry a few months ago. But these days state aid, and how to dole it out, are ...