Submit a Story!
National Accounts Show Stimulus Did Not Fuel GDP Growth
National Accounts Show Stimulus Did Not Fuel GDP Growth
Along with the news that real GDP growth improved from -0.7 percent in the second quarter to 3.5 percent in the fourth quarter, the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) released detailed National Income and Product Account tables yesterday, which received little comment in the press today. These ...
A welcome GDP report
A welcome GDP report
econbrowser.com — The Commerce Department reported today that the seasonally adjusted real value of the nation's production of goods... and services grew at a 3.5% annual rate during the third quarter, a little better than the 3.2% average seen since 1947.  ... (more) A welcome GDP report
Baseline Scenario, October 30, 2009
baselinescenario.com — Yesterday morning I testified to a Joint Economic Committee of Congress hearing. The session discussed the latest... GDP numbers, the impact of the fiscal stimulus earlier this year, and whether we need further fiscal expansion of any kind. I argued that a global recovery is underway and in ... (more) Baseline Scenario, October 30, 2009
The GDP Mirage
The GDP Mirage
businessweek.com — By overlooking cuts in research and development, product design, and worker training, GDP is greatly overstating the... economy's strength (more) The GDP Mirage
Comments
Blog Reactions

Did the stimulus work?
Cafe Hayek — Jeffrey Miron, Simon Johnson, Mark Thoma and I answer the question here. Here is John Taylor’s answer.

Amidst the Euphoria: Thoughts about Jobs and GDP
MV=PQ: A Resource for Economic Educators — ... or about any administration, and I underscore any administration about its ability to create, save, destroy is optimistic at best. Unless everyone is employed by government and in a very small economy, there is just no way to work through the details of every job to verify the claim. The best one can do in a very large, dynamic economy is look at net gains/losses in jobs. And even then, to claim success or blame failure on a specific program is questionable. The second item is a post from John Taylor's blog. He does a good, short analysis of the recently released third ...

Related: how much did stimulus help 3.5% gdp growth
The 2009Q3 Advance GDP Release and Stimulus Measures
econbrowser.com 10/30/2009 — The 3.5% growth rate was, in my view, in large part attributable to direct measures to stimulate the economy, including direct spending on goods and services by the government (Federal, state and local), as well as tax measures. First, let's take a ...
Stimulus, Growth and Recovery: The Debate ContinuesThe Powell Perspective
There is growing intelligent dissent to the administration’s stimulus policy. Critics argue that recent growth is the result of market principles. Edward P. Lazear wrote Monday in the WSJ, that he forecasted a return to growth without stimulus spending. He goes on to argue, along with ...
Government Site to CheckAngry Bear
Mish sends us to " Track the Money ," recovery.gov's breakdown of where funds have been sent and spent. He's not happy, but I suspect he's suffering the Jared Bernstein Problem : only looking at one side of the equation. But—and this is the key "but"—the reason it is right to do that ...
"A Shaky Start"Economist's View
I have something at Room for Debate (written last Friday) on the the extent to which the recent improvement in GDP growth can be attributed to the stimulus package, and whether more stimulus is needed (" Did the Stimulus Work? "). The link is to the much shorter version that ...
"A Shaky Start"Economist's View
HTML clipboard I have something at Room for Debate (written last Friday) on the the extent to which the recent improvement in GDP growth can be attributed to the stimulus package, and whether more stimulus is needed (" Did the Stimulus Work? "). The link is to the much shorter ...
The China Stimulus Follies24/7 Wall St.
China managed to pull another rabbit out of its growth hat. The world’s most populous nation said its GDP grew 8.9% in the third quarter. Some outside analysts are skeptical about how China keeps its records of such things, but its economy is clearly growing faster than that of any other ...
Fiscal Imprudence and Fiscal Stimulus-BeckerThe Becker-Posner Blog
The government's preliminary estimate of the growth in American GDP during the third quarter of 2009 is an impressive annual rate of 3.5%. This figure may be revised downward (or upward) as more data on the third quarter become available, but it surely definitely signals that the US recession ...
5 Big Reasons Why You Should Doubt The US GDP GrowthDaily Markets
It’s true, the 3.5 percent third quarter GDP growth could be a sign of good things to come… but most likely that’s not the case. Brian Sullivan of FBN has put together five reasons why the US is not recovering. 1. The money lost on stimulus spending - The 3.5 percent growth ...
The Death of Private InvestmentCato @ Liberty
The Bureau of Economic Analysis released third-quarter gross domestic product numbers yesterday, and overall real growth at 3.5 percent was pretty good. But examining the components of GDP reveals a more disturbing picture. While consumption, exports, and the government sector were up, ...
Mild Pullback for Stocks After GDP Rally (Market Update)SmartMoney.com
Investors catch their breath and ponder the impact of stimulus on growth results.
GDP Growth 3.5% in 3rd QuarterEconomist's View
The stimulus package in action: GDP Expanded 3.5% in 3rd Quarter, WSJ : The economy expanded in the third quarter after shrinking for four consecutive quarters, likely marking an end to the worst recession since World War II. But the recovery is expected to be slow, as the economy ...
Stimulus Spending Boosts GDP and Stocks (Market Update)SmartMoney.com
Surprise growth of 3.5% sends major indexes up at market open.