Submit a Story!
Permanent vs. temporary increases in government spending, a Keynesian approach
Let's say government can spend $100 billion today or spend the present expected value of $100 billion, stretched out over time so it is a commitment in perpetuity.  Both spending programs are financed by bonds.  So that's the same net present value of spending and the same method of ...
Permanent vs. temporary increases in government consumption
marginalrevolution.com — Paul Krugman writes : ...he [Brad DeLong] fails to note that it’s not just wrong, it’s 180... degrees wrong: a temporary increase in government spending should have a larger impact on demand than a permanent increase, not a smaller impact. I intend my ... (more) Permanent vs. temporary increases in government consumption
Comments
Blog Reactions

Temporary vs. Permanent
EconLog: Library of Economics and LibertyTyler Cowen weighs in on an issue that has been bouncing around the blogosphere. Overall the Keynesian effects can mean either the permanent or the temporary spending boost has a bigger effect and there are also a number of ways of defining what a "bigger effect" might mean. I assume that when a household gets a check from the government--either a tax rebate or a spending payment--the household assumes that someone else is paying for it. That is, I break Ricardian equivalence. However, bondholders are forward-looking, so that a permanent increase in spending raises interest ...

I do not think that word …
Paul Krugman — … means what Tyler Cowen and Megan McArdle think it means. The word in question is “spending.” Tyler’s latest on temporary versus permanent government consumption clarifies what the confusion is over my ...

Economics of Government Spending
Lawrance G. Lux — ... Tyler Cowen brings a good discussion of Keynesian effect to the discussion. I know only that long-run economic performance determines the capital investment made into the sectors, and that investment schedules are particularly immune to Keynesian spending past the immediate period of that expenditure. The market corrects for impression mistakes in rapid order, and it is likely that Keynesian spending should be compressed to have any effect. I believe the problem with Keynesian spending is that it insists on continuous provision of funds to maintain a constant performance; this ...

First, We Kill All the Economists
Paul Kedrosky's Infectious Greed — ... inability of prominent economists to talk to one another in the same language with words meaning the same thing and not freighted with a metric ton (or ten) of political baggage. Another temporary misunderstanding (Krugman) Permanent vs. temporary increases in government consumption (Cowen) Read before linking (wonkish) (Krugman) Permanent vs. temporary increases in government spending, a Keynesian approach (Cowen) I do not think that word … (Krugman) If nothing else, ...

Lying Stimuli
Overcoming Bias — ... from B, not only do A and B benefit but the downturn is reduced a bit as well.  (In an upturn, extra activity arguably exasperates the boom-bust cycle.)  This fact can justify subsidizing economic activity a bit more (or taxing it a bit less) during a downturn.  But it turns out this isn't the main rationale for the "economic stimuli" now being debated; those plans are largely based on the idea that people can be fooled because they are biased.  Tyler Cowen:  ...

Related Content
Another temporary misunderstanding
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com 2/1/2009 — Brad DeLong links to Megan McArdle saying something wrong about the effects of a temporary increase in government spending. But he fails to note that it's not just wrong, it's 180 degrees wrong: a temporary increase in government spending should have ...
Avoiding Permanent Losses of Capital
michaelcovel.com 2/14/2009 — How do you avoid a permanent loss of capital? Simple. Have a pre-defined exit strategy before you ever enter a market. What is another way to answer that question? Motley Fool offers this : 1. Shareholders who didn’t anticipate the ...
The Keynesian moment
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com 11/30/2008 — Greg has this exactly right: IF you were going to turn to only one economist to understand the problems facing the economy, there is little doubt that the economist would be John Maynard Keynes. Although Keynes died more than a half-century ago, his ...
How Much of the Increase is Permanent?
economistsview.typepad.com 7/25/2009 — [pop-up]
Why Permanent Tax Cuts Are the Best Stimulus
online.wsj.com 11/25/2008 — The incoming Obama administration and congressional Democrats are now considering a second fiscal stimulus package, estimated at more than $500 billion, to follow the Economic Stimulus Act of 2008. As they do, much can be learned by examining the ...
All stimulus, all the time
meganmcardle.theatlantic.com 2/3/2009 — Paul Krugman clarifies his point about temporary versus permanent spending: Tyler's latest on temporary versus permanent government consumption clarifies what the confusion is over my very simple point . I don't think Tyler understands what I (and ...
Avoiding Permanent Losses of Capital
fool.com 2/14/2009 — It's a dreadful time for the stock market. Fear has struck Wall Street, and with investors panicking about the future of our economy, stock prices plunge sickeningly. But how do you differentiate between general fluctuations in the market and ...
That's the Keynesian Spirit!
blog.mises.org 1/27/2009 — The Arlington (Va.) Connection reports that Congressman Jim Moran convened an "emergency meeting of local leaders" last week to discuss the best way to carve up funds from the yet-to-be-passed Democratic "stimulus" package: The bill, which was ...
Timely? Temporary?
econlog.econlib.org 1/27/2009 — (January 26, 2009 06:41 PM, by Arnold Kling) Douglas Elmendorf, the head of the Congressional Budget Office, writes, CBO estimates that enacting the bill would increase federal budget deficits by $169 billion over the remaining months of fiscal year ...
Partisan, Pandering, Permanent
econlog.econlib.org 1/28/2009 — (January 28, 2009 08:43 AM, by Arnold Kling) From The New York Times: The economic stimulus plan that Congress has scheduled for a vote on Wednesday would shower the nation's school districts, child care centers and university campuses with $150 ...