Submit a Story!
The Consumer Financial Protection Agency Act Is Flawed
RICHARD A. POSNER Will the epitaph of the Obama administration be “too much, too soon, too costly”? Among worrisome signs is its proposed Consumer Financial Protection Agency Act of 2009. The agency would have regulatory authority over retail financial products such as mortgages and credit ...
Three Myths about the Consumer Financial Product Agency
baselinescenario.com — This guest post was contributed by Elizabeth Warren , chair of the Congressional Oversight Panel and the Leo Gottlieb Professor of Law at Harvard University. I’ve written a lot about the creation of a new Consumer Protection Financial Agency (CFPA), starting with an article I wrote in the ... (more) Three Myths about the Consumer Financial Product Agency
Why Banks Should Support a Consumer Financial Protection Agency
Why Banks Should Support a Consumer Financial Protection Agency
economix.blogs.nytimes.com — In a food contamination scare, people buy less of that food until the government assures them that it understands the problem and the contamination will not happen again. The same goes for a scare over the dangers of financial products, an economist ... (more) Why Banks Should Support a Consumer Financial Protection ...
Financial Consumer Agency of Canada
fcac-acfc.gc.ca — Symbol of the Government of Canada maple leaf Financial Consumer Agency of Canada www.fcac-acfc.gc.ca Skip to content | Skip to institutional links Common menu bar links Fran ais Home Contact Us Help Search canada.gc.ca Home Institutional links | ... (more) Financial Consumer Agency of Canada
Comments
Blog Reactions

links for 2009-07-23
Economist's View — ... Things which probably aren't true - Free exchange Reducing Systemic Risk in the Financial Sector - Brookings Institution The Consumer Financial Protection Agency Act Is Flawed - Richard Posner Mindless ...

Some Antitrust Links
TRUTH ON THE MARKET — ... offers up some analysis the recently filed Ed O’Bannon v. NCAA challenging the NCAA’s use and license of former student-athletes’ identifies in various commercial ventures OK, its not exactly antitrust, but Richard Posner’s criticism of a new Consumer Protection Financial Agency based on the insights of behavioral economics is worth reading.  Posner points out that following investment advice borne of behavioral economics a decade ago to invest more in equities to avoid “myopic loss aversion” would not have been a good decision and ends with the important point that is ...

Traditional Chicago Economics Under Pressure: Beyond The Thaler-Posner Debate
The Baseline Scenario — ... Richard Posner is against the proposed new Consumer Financial Protection Agency (CFPA).  This is, of course, not a surprise.  Posner has always been an articulate advocate of the view most often associated with economics at the University of Chicago: market-based outcomes are invariably better than the alternatives, and anything that interferes with consumer choice is a bad idea.  ...

Plain Vanilla Mortgages
Economist's View — ... A mere 17 days after Thaler's NYT debut, I opened the Wall St. Journal op-ed page and spotted an essay by ... Richard Posner... I was all eyes, and the headline -- Treating Financial Consumers as Consenting Adults ... intrigued me. ... ...

Richard Thaler Explains Behavioral Economics to Richard Posner
The Baseline Scenario — ... Richard Posner, who usually shows at least some subtlety in his reasoning, trotted out all the usual Republican talking points against the Consumer Financial Protection Agency in the Wall Street Journal, choosing to attack Richard Thaler along the way for no apparent good reason. The core of his argument is that since Thaler has previously advocated investing a larger proportion of one’s portfolio in stocks, and this would have been a bad strategy in 2008, he cannot possibly be right when it comes to financial regulation. I’m not kidding – ...

Dear Richard (Posner), Love Richard (Thaler)
Paul Kedrosky's Infectious Greed — ... There is a nice note from behavioral economist Richard Thaler to law & economics sort Richard Posner out. The former takes the latter to task for his WSJ OpEd criticizing his support of a Consumer Financial Protection Agency. ...

Thaler vs Posner on Consumer Financial Protections
FinanceProfessor.com — ... (which by the way is well worth reading and even if you only read the interview on the Amzon page you will learn much.) Thaler and Sunstein suggest that by should take human behavior (i.e. behavioral finance/economics) into account when considering "choice architecture". Seemingly this idea has taken root and large parts of it are being adopted and as such has more or less been in the news weekly for the past few months. Not all are happy with this and recently Richard Posner took issue with the proposed changes in a WSJ opinion piece : "...the agency might [emphasis is ...

Related Content
Congress Gets Financial Protection Agency Plan
nytimes.com 6/30/2009 — WASHINGTON — The Obama administration sent Congress a detailed proposal on Tuesday to create a consumer protection agency responsible for financial products, a move that is the first shot in a heated battle with banks and other financial institutions ...
Three Problematic Truths About the Consumer Financial Protection Agency Act of 2009 | FinReg21|Reforming Financial Services Regulation in the 21st Century
finreg21.com 9/17/2009 — The creation of a new Consumer Financial Protection Agency (“CFPA”) is a very bad idea and should be rejected. The proposal is not salvageable and cannot be improved in substance or in form. The proposal is premised on a fundamental misunderstanding ...
Obama's Vision For Consumer Protection Agency Now Moves To Congress
onthehillblog.blogspot.com 10/10/2009 — After months of drumming up support to create a new federal agency to prevent another financial meltdown, President Obama's proposal to establish the Consumer Financial Protection Agency will go before lawmakers next week.
Elizabeth Warren Defends The Consumer Financial Protection Agency
dailybail.com 8/4/2009 — Harvard Professor and Head of the Congressional Oversight Panel for TARP, Dr. Elizabeth Warren explains why America needs a Consumer Financial Protection Agency, CFPA. (July 16, 2009, Cambridge, Massachusetts) Watch  
Video: Obama pushes consumer protection
politicalnewslive.blogspot.com 10/10/2009 — In a speech promoting a Consumer Financial Protection Agency, the U.S. President accuses financial firms of maximizing profits at the expense of Americans.
Waiting For The Big Push: Selling The Consumer Protection Agency For Financial Products
baselinescenario.com 7/13/2009 — In mid-March, the administration proposed that toxic assets could and would be safely removed from banks balance sheets. We were skeptical , and the the PPIP now seems to have slipped into irrelevance ( loans ; securities ). But the administration still put an impressive effort into ...
Sen. Dodd urges consumer finance protection agency (Reuters)
news.yahoo.com 6/13/2009 — Reuters - U.S. Senate Banking Committee Chairman Christopher Dodd on Thursday called for creation of an independent consumer protection agency as part of wider reforms to the U.S. financial regulatory structure.
Consumer Protection: Reverse Convertibles
rortybomb.wordpress.com 6/18/2009 — Since we’ve already run new stress tests out of this webpage, I’m going to go ahead and run the Consumer Protection Agency out of the Rortybomb Blog while President Obama and team continue to get the legislation worked out. (If I keep ...
Credit Conditions In The Absence Of Consumer Protection
baselinescenario.com 8/10/2009 — Even some of our most sophisticated commentators doubt a link between consumer protection and any macroeconomic outcomes. Consumer protection, in this view, is microeconomics and quite different from macroeconomic issues (such as the speed and nature of our economic recovery). Officially ...
Consumer Protection Elitists? Hardly
economistsview.typepad.com 7/14/2009 — Richard Green takes on Peter Wallison's arguments against establishing a Financial Product Safety Commission: Peter Wallison calls Consumer Protection Elitist : He writes : Traditionally, consumer protection in the United States has focused ...