Submit a Story!
Will the Geithner Plan Work?
Will the Geithner Plan Work?
Paul Krugman, Simon Johnson, Brad DeLong and Mark Thoma on the government plan to buy up bad mortgage assets.
Geithner: My Plan for Bad Bank Assets
Geithner: My Plan for Bad Bank Assets
online.wsj.com — TIMOTHY GEITHNER The American economy and much of the world now face extraordinary challenges, and confronting these... challenges will continue to require extraordinary actions. No crisis like this has a simple or single cause, but as a nation we ... (more) Geithner: My Plan for Bad Bank Assets
Geithner plan arithmetic
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com — Leave on one side the question of whether the Geither plan is a good idea or not.... One thing is clearly false in the way it's being presented: administration officials keep saying that there's no subsidy involved, that investors would share in the ... (more) Geithner plan arithmetic
More on the bank plan
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com — Why was I so quick to condemn the Geithner plan? Because it's not new; it's just another... version of an idea that keeps coming up and keeps being refuted. It's basically a thinly disguised version of the same plan Henry Paulson announced way back in ... (more) More on the bank plan
Comments
Blog Reactions

"Will the Geithner Plan Work?"
Economist's View — ... How to Tell It’s Working, by Mark Thoma, Room for Debate, NY Times Blogs: A bailout plan must do two things to be effective. It must remove toxic assets from bank balance sheets, and it must recapitalize banks in a politically acceptable manner. I believe the Geithner plan has a chance of doing both of these things, but it’s by no means a sure bet that it will. ...

Room for Debate
Paul Krugman — March 24, 2009, 1:38 pm Room for Debate See more opinions and morning-after thoughts, including mine, about the Geithner plan at The Times’s discussion forum, Room for Debate . ...

The Geithner Plan
Conglomerate — ... Second, Paul Krugman has raised all sorts of problems by criticizing the Program (for a nice debate involving Krugman, Simon Johnson, Brad DeLong, and Mark Thoma, see here), but his main point is pretty simple: no matter what the Obama Administration says, the Geithner Plan is a subsidy to banks and private equity investors ( ...

Room For Debate At The NYT
The Baseline Scenario — ... The NYT is ran an online discussion of the new Geithner Plan yesterday.  The worry I expressed there is whether the Plan is scalable - i.e., it could work at a modest level, but to really have impact it needs to be huge.  And, as it gets larger, I think we’ll see a political backlash. ...

The Geithner Plan: Time Is Not on Our Side
EconoSpeak — Here is the short version of what Simon Johnson, Paul Krugman, Brad DeLong and Mark Thoma said in their discussion of Geithner’s PPIP: no one thinks it is likely to be adequate, Johnson/DeLong/Thoma express varying degrees of optimism that it can lay the political groundwork for more decisive action down the road, and Krugman fears the Obama administration is using up what remains of its political capital and will be unable to take any further action. ...

“Toxicity” Is A State of Mind
A Fistful Of Euros » A Fistful Of Euros — You know, one of the things which amazes me about the discourse which surrounds this crisis is the way people seem to trot out all the old formulae, without giving a moments though to what they mean. “In the long run we are all dead” is an obvious case, who really stops for long enough nowadays to think about what Keynes was actually getting at? “Animal Spirits” would be another. The New York Times are running an interesting forum, called “Room For Debate“. Now Brad DeLong makes the following point (drat, you ...

What do you mean “Fix It?”
macroblog — ... if you somehow feel you might have missed one—but the New York Times' Room for Debate feature is a reasonable place to get a one-stop view of some divergent opinions the plan has elicited. ...

Related: us government buy bad assets, geithner krugman delong
Brad DeLong's defense of Geithner
krugman.blogs.nytimes.com 3/22/2009 — Brad gives it the old college try. But he shies away, I think, from the central issue: the non-recourse loans financing 85 percent of the purchases. Brad treats the prospect that assets purchased by public-private partnership will fall enough in value ...
The Great Unclog of 2009: Industrial Strength Drano, Anyone?
dailybail.com 3/23/2009 — Why Paul Krugman , James Galbraith , Simon Johnson and John Hussman are right and Brad Delong, Tim Geithner and Lawrence Summers are very, very wrong. The issue is Treasury Secretary Geithner's solution to the banking crisis revealed this morning. The mother of all bailouts is actually ...
Will the Geithner Plan Work?J. Bradford DeLong's Grasping Reality with All Eight Tentacles
Mark Thoma is on the case: Economist's View: "Will the Geithner Plan Work?" : The question is, "Will the Geithner plan work?" There are responses from Paul Krugman, Brad DeLong, Simon Johnson, and me...
U.S. Rounding Up Investors to Buy Bad AssetsIEHI Feed: The Hedge Fund Implode-o-Meter
" Obama administration officials worked Sunday to persuade reluctant private investors to buy as much as $1 trillion in troubled mortgages and related assets from banks, with government help."
U.S. Rounding Up Investors to Buy Bad AssetsDealBook
Obama administration officials worked Sunday to persuade reluctant private investors to buy as much as $1 trillion in troubled mortgages and related assets from banks, with government help, The New York Times's Andrew Ross Sorkin, Eric Dash and Rachel L. Swarns reported. The talks came a day ...
Someone has to be wrongMarginal Revolution
Paul Krugman thinks Brad DeLong is wrong .  Brad DeLong thinks that Paul Krugman is wrong .  Robert Waldmann thinks that Brad DeLong is wrong .  The topic of course is the Geithner plan. I'm not so far from Kevin Drum's view, as stated here and here .  It has some chance ...
US urges investors to buy bad assetsFT Alphaville
Obama administration officials worked Sunday to persuade reluctant private investors to buy as much as $1,000bn in troubled mortgages and related assets from banks, with government help, reports the NYT. The talks came the day before Treasury secretary Tim Geithner is due to unveil details of ...